|
The award-winning
author of many volumes of poetry, Jonathan Holden is better known for
his verse than his essays. But he thinks the two genres are related to
each other, and that this relationship is illustrated by the process he
went through in writing his essay "Imaginary Fathers."
"Confessional poetry
and personal memoir are codependent," Holden said. The relationship between
his essay and his poems lies in their use of language: his essay "digresses,"
he said, while his poems "condense" language.
"This essay, like
all of my personal essays, recapitulates subject matter that I have written
about in poems," he said. "The personal essay seems to me to be the genre
most similar to lyric poetry when the poetry is personal, confessional-but
it differs from poetry in that, whereas the conventions of poetry encourage
condensation, the conventions of prose encourage digression.
As a result, he concluded,
"Prose may be superior to poetry, because of the permission prose gives
the writer to digress and supply context that, in a lyric poem, would
attenuate its intensity."
In his essay Holden
explores growing up with a scientist-father who did not pay him as much
attention as he wanted. Holden said the digression encouraged by the essay-form
permitted him to make several discoveries during the writing process,
discoveries he had not made in writing poems about his father.
"The discovery I
made when writing it was that, in my 'strategic' approach to raising my
son, I was putting into practice a 'scientific' approach to 'love' that
my father, however inadvertently, had taught me," Holden said. "I discovered
that, by loving my son better than my father had loved me, I could be
an ideal version of my own father-could enjoy his love retroactively while
fathering a son better than myself."
In permitting himself
the luxury of the digression that comes with writing prose, Holden also
encountered another problem writers sometimes face: the desire to wreak
vengeance.
"It was a difficult
essay to write, because its subject was a painful one. I had to try to
resist the impulse to exact revenge on a scientist whose preoccupation
with himself and his career came before his duties as a father."

|